Written by Tom Bewick
This article was first published in BrexitCentral and we republish with their kind permission
~~~ *** ~~~
As the socialist tribes descend on Brighton once again, Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour Party finds itself in the grip of a full blown civil war. The Momentum faction wants to depose deputy leader Tom Watson, and his Blairite kind, in good old Marxist-Leninist style: if you can’t take out your opponent democratically, then just abolish their post. Meanwhile, Jeremy Corbyn himself – according to comparable polling data – has just secured the ignominious title of being the most unpopular opposition leader since 1977. And all this, just weeks before an inevitable general election.
In times gone by, a serious opposition party would be miles ahead in the opinion polls. Party discipline would be watertight, even if for the selfish reason that the electorate has rarely put into power such a divided team. There will be many, now middle-aged, Labour voters, who remember 1977 rather fondly; and in particular the Queen’s Silver Jubilee of that year. For it was not only the Sex Pistols making scurrilous headlines performing God Save the Queen. The year of the Jubilee also saw giant street parties in everyday working communities up and down the land.
In this era, even Labour was an unequivocally patriotic party: working-class bonds like faith, family and flag were not to be ridiculed and certainly never sneered at. What, then, must all these grown-up voters think of Emily Thornberry? As a shadow minister, she was sacked by Ed Miliband when he was Labour leader, for condescendingly poking fun at a blue-collar worker’s house proudly displaying the flag of St. George. Fast forward to the eve of this year’s Labour Party conference and Thornberry was seen at a People’s Vote rally all dressed up and bejewelled in the federalist stars of the EU. And without, it would seem, any apparent sense of self-awareness or irony, Thornberry led a chant of ‘this is what democracy looks like’! It was as if, in the Westminster bubble that had temporarily relocated to the seaside, the second referendum Remain leadership inside the Labour Party had completely taken all leave of its senses.
From afar, the self-proclaimed people’s republic of Brighton and Hove looks like the Corbyn cult embarking upon a final death wish. Because by so actively trashing the dignity and the decision of 5 million Labour supporters who voted to leave the EU in 2016, you can’t help but conclude that the real plan of old Blairites like Watson and Thornberry is to sink Corbyn and Momentum so far below the water line, that Labour goes down to one of its biggest electoral defeats.
Corbyn himself appears oblivious to the total incredulity of his latest ridiculous Brexit position. As a Member of Parliament of 36 years standing, he has more Eurosceptic DNA inside him than Jacob Rees-Mogg and Peter Bone put together. On every occasion, before becoming Labour leader, Corbyn voted against European treaties that have increasingly robbed Britain of its sovereignty in the pursuit of ever closer political union. Now Corbyn can’t even say if he would be pro-Leave or pro-Remain in a second referendum facilitated by a future Labour government – of which he is hoping to be the Prime Minister. Like a medieval bishop overseeing some baronial dispute, Corbyn is hedging his bets, piously sitting on the fence, hoping somehow that his approach will eventually cut through to a divided nation eternally grateful for the wisdom of St. Jeremy.
As Foreign Secretary in a future Labour government, Emily Thornberry would be despatched to Brussels “to get the best possible Brexit deal”. Quite why the EU would agree any favourable terms with such a political temptress, who has already telegraphed in advance that she would campaign against her own negotiating position, beggars belief. Indeed, it would be like Len McCluskey of Unite saying he would happily go and negotiate a new pay deal for his members, only to campaign against his own union’s recommendation when put back to the ballot: McCluskey would be laughed out of town.
Karl Marx famously said that history often repeats itself, “the first as tragedy, and then as farce.” The Labour Party under Jeremy Corbyn took the tragic decision in the summer of 2017, after the last general election, to immediately start undermining the result of the EU referendum. Instead of sticking to the party’s own manifesto commitments, of getting Britain out of all the institutions of the EU, Labour has deliberately tried to thwart the largest democratic mandate in British history. Led by Sir Keir Starmer, the party’s ‘constructive ambiguity’ architect, Labour has moved its position from one of breath-taking incredulity to a full-blown farce. Millions of traditional Labour voters are now observing, in total horror, the party of Keir Hardie, Nye Bevan, Clement Attlee and Barbara Castle tearing itself apart.
Corbyn had his chance to stay true to his own convictions regarding the undemocratic nature of the EU. He could have chosen to lead; instead he has turned out to be no more than a puppet of a hard-left Remain sect. The Labour Party – following the convulsive events of June 2016 – had a golden opportunity to reconnect with everyday working people in the Midlands, the North and South Wales. Instead, the destiny the current middle-class membership has actively chosen is one of representing only graduates, public sector workers and the liberal metropolitan elite. Any psephology student will tell you that there is no path back to power for the party, by actively going against the democratic wishes of two-thirds of Labour Leave supporting seats in the House of Commons. What we are now witnessing is probably the death throes of the old party of the working class. At the last general election, the Conservatives managed to attract more support from C2, D and E voters than Labour. At the forthcoming general election, particularly if the Tories respond positively to Nigel Farage’s non-aggression pact, the Brexit Party are set to take Corbyn’s Labour Party to the cleaners. Like Monty Python’s dead parrot sketch, Labour is finished. It has ceased to exist.
The Labour Party has never been for us surfs, that was just a myth by them to get votes. Ramsey Macdonald pre ww2. Being a baby boomer, I know just how poor the working class were after ww2, things did get better round 1960, The labour got in, just before I left school at 15, I had no vote, they got in again when I was 20,I had no vote,then they got in again did about 3 years. During that time they made working class people poorer, but did give plenty to those that did not work. Many do not remember 35% paye and plus 5% for graduated pension. Total 40 % of what you earnt, and we had purchase tax on top. Not forgetting lab then reduced the agreed pay of Grad pension by 50% three times. they scammed us.
Result I hate Labour, have never voted labour, they are just one lot of rich telling us we are being robbed by other rich ones, and all the time they are the ones screwing us.
With Labour in us working surfs do not need sex, we get screwed by labour ever minute of every day.
IT HAS TO BE FACED UP TO. – LABOUR HAS LOST THE PLOT ENTIRELY UNDER CORBYN !
Although I hardly ever agreed with the Labour Party in six decades of my voting, I used to have a degree of respect for that Party in sticking to their Socialist values. – The rot set in from Blair onwards !
Chatting to my family, I was asked about Politics in general, and the inevitable question was asked. – ”What does the Labour Party stand for today” ? ….. The only answer I could give, was – ANYTHING THAT GETS THEM VOTES !
I was not trying to be in any way nasty about Labour, but thinking about my reply, it is a fact ! If we take an old Father of the Party; – Keir Hardie MP, he was absolute Socialist, and is on record as having no time for Karl Marx’s ideas !
I wonder why Tom Bewick’s name could not have appeared instead of “guest author”. He was until last May a Labour Councillor in Brighton and Hove and chairman of the education committee. He is now set to become the next MP for Hastings and Rye now that Amber Rudd has fled the scene.
I hope he wipes the floor with the last traitorous MP if she dares to stand. Labour too have this past week shown at their ridiculous conference up for what they are really about, a neo Marxist Party with no real belief in democracy. I keep on reading that the British don’t like extremes implying that every party to the right of the Conservatives are neo Fascist parties, which they patently are not. However the same description can be applied to the Labour Party, who are now led by extremists through and through. They just will not get the votes………..
Enjoyed the article but no voters are more unthinking and tribalist than Labour voters. The hope is that this whole sorry business has reawakened peoples’ political awareness and engagement. However it’s not just the party of graduates, civil serpents and metroliberals. There are the millions of bludgers and immigrants who are happy on the free money plantation.
Liebore have just jumped the shark and voted to have completely open borders in their next manifesto. No restrictions whatsoever and immediate benefits and vote for the new arrivals. That’ll sell well in the NE.
“If you have a pulse we will take you; if you don’t we will take your vote’.
I am a graduate. I was shunted into the civil service before going to university and then somehow kept getting forced back after graduation. If those people are the ones who support Labour – well, it’s like I said yesterday, today’s Uni bears no relationship to the University I attended 1968 – 71.
Many Labour voters, probably are now the ‘don’t work, live on benefits’ class. I know one (so called student) and have read of others. Also I’m sure many immigrants have come for a free ride. On the other hand I was talking with a Polish lady, excellent english, working as receptionist in our health centre. I asked why she had come, ‘For the economy’. I just said ‘And I’m sure it will still be good after brexit.’ My health centre is not a place for political discussion but somehow I cannot imagine that young lady being guilty of supporting the particular labour MP so called representing me in the HoC at the moment. Ruth George goes around the constituency twisting statistics, whipping up project fear and generally making a song and dance about how slavishly she follows Corbyn’s every utterance. Do you think perhaps she is determined to remain in her marginal seat?
The whole thing STINKS. UK is too crowded. Don’t care if I am labeled racist – there are too many Muslims moving in and setting up their own enclaves. If the EU wants immigrants let them keep them. That particular Polish lady is welcome to stay she works in the NHS and does a good job.
As for the Labour Party the way it is now, I hope it DIES. I never liked them anyway and at the moment they are outright TRAITORS.
Perhaps more accurately it should be “undergraduates and academics” rather than graduates. The East Europeans working here are ineligible to vote in general elections – only British, Irish or some Commonwealth citizens/subjects can vote in these. British means anyone from anywhere with a UK passport these days as they have been handed out with no thought, care or responsibility particularly in the last 20 years and have thus been greatly devalued.
Pauline, having lived that period myself, I agree particularly in respect of the Muslim problem. The issues that they create are simply part of their nature; it was always going to be so. Perhaps those in government who allowed, even encouraged, it should have read the fable of the scorpion and the frog first and thought about it.
Very well put, and true.
Regarding the Thornberry comments in the article, I actually applaud her being open about her distaste for the flag and the working class who are patriotic. I can respect someone who tells the truth and lets you know exactly where you stand with them, that way you know who and what you are fighting against. What I cannot abide and which we see in all our political parties is the mealy mouthed and sly attempt to appeal to all, and once in power, well we know how that plays out. The Country is too divided by mass immigration and now by the Brexit scandal/farce, so watching career politicians trying to appeal to all just churns my stomach.
Labour may never recover but I’m not sure the Tories will either, we have to wonder then, just who is going to run the country and are we ever going to have strong leadership again?
Power vacuums are dangerous, no matter how bad our leaders are, there’s always somebody or something worse waiting in the wings, in this case I’m very sure that something is the European Union.
Let’s face it, we can’t even have an election now, our democracy is just about dead and very likely we’ve played right into the hands of the EU, this current scenario is a dream opportunity for them.
First act of business for a new government , if we ever get another one which is debatable, is to abolish the FTPA before they even sit down. This abomination has got us completely stuck in a morass.
I believe that the FTPA was something concocted by Nick Clegg during the coalition. This just goes to show that the Lib/Dems are totally unfit to exercise any sort of executive power.
Bad legislation that ought to have been scrutinized and picked to bits by the Parliament and the Lords. Thought they had law degrees some of them? To serve its original purpose all they had to do was pass an amendment to sunset it after 5 years I.e. remove it from the statute books before the 2015 election.
to MWT Yes I agree about FTPA. Passed by Cameron/Clegg wasn’t it. Probably the first Remain conspiracy.
”Played right into the hands of the EU”? I don’t think so. This whole scenario has been choreographed by the EU. It’s not a case of ”playing into their hands” – it’s a case of walking straight into their trap.
At least, it would have been – except that BJ might just be strangely unpredictable enough to spring their trap BEFORE we get snapped up.