Yes – it’s again about ‘them’ …
According to our MSM, nothing worth reporting has happened yesterday except one thing: the England women’s football team beat Germany at Wembley 2:1, winning the Euro 2022 Cup. The headline writers went into overdrive, the gist of these efforts being ‘Roarsome Lionesses’. If you feel so inclined, you can check out the print editions’ front pages in the usual place (link).
Also-ran ‘news’ are that more and more Tory heavyweights are endorsing Truss – Zahawi and Iain Duncan Smith being the latest. Oh, and Sunak ‘promises’ to cut income tax by 4% … has no-one told him that he’s not going to be elected by the whole of the British voting public?
For the broadsheets, the ‘Toree Race’ is over. It’s Truss who should take on the role of PM. The important point for the Westminster political correspondents is that this spectacle means they don’t have to look at, never mind write about, Labour or Starmer who has a ten-point lead over any of the putative Tory MPs. There’s one article worth mentioning which was published in ConHome. The headline is stunning:
“This leadership election. At best, a damp squib. At worst, self-destructive. Either way, not up to the challenge. Why ConservativeHome isn’t endorsing a candidate yet. If we do at all.” (link)
After bemoaning the vitriolic tweets by both Truss and Sunak’s ‘activists’ we read that two of the eliminated candidates weren’t gentle loyalists either. Well, that’s ‘business as usual’. It’s not really about MPs ‘blurting out confidential discussions’ but about tweets and ‘leaks’ by selected ‘sources’ which have been driving politics for too long. This observation should concentrate the minds especially of ‘supporting MPs’:
“Robust debate is one thing; self-destructiveness is another – inflamed by TV’s pursuit of ratings, social media’s feeding frenzy, the craze for celebrity and the way we live now. For make no mistake: the most likely winner of this frenzied contest so far is…Keir Starmer. Labour sails on as I write, seven points ahead in Politico’s poll of polls – gleefully filing away these gibes, assaults and demolitions of each other’s programmes: all to be projected during the run-up to September, while the splits and sackings in Keir Starmer’s own team grab less attention.” (link)
The article throws a light on the vapidity of this whole spectacle. It’s driven by the MSM whose agenda is to crown Starmer as next PM, not by Tory members or indeed us voters.
And so to the essay written by Kemi Badenoch for The Times’ weekend edition. At first glance it looks like yet another article about the Tavistock Clinic, utilised to describe the ‘life as a minister’. It is in fact a description of how mandarins make politics. Ms Badenoch uses the Tavistock Clinic issue to show how, in her experience, mandarins manipulated government’s policy. Put down your drinks and sit tight before you read this:
“The government machine wants to be comfortable and consensual and campaigners and activists know how to take advantage of this. A minister asking tricky questions can be stopped in their tracks by accusations of stoking “culture wars”. Minutes of private meetings with whistleblowers and concerned citizens can be selectively leaked or become the subject of numerous innocent-looking freedom of information requests, designed to identify targets for harassment on social media, as I discovered in one unfortunate case.” (link, paywalled)
That unfortunate case is the operation of the Tavistock Clinic and the whole trans issue. I suggest in the margins that it applies equally to the Immigration issue and how Ms Patel has been ‘played’ by her mandarins. There’s more:
“Whitehall has solutions for ministers wishing to dodge difficult decisions: issue another call for evidence for information you already have; publish a consultation that is captured by campaigners or form a new working group of “stakeholders”. However, the work of government is all about making difficult decisions, even if it makes us unpopular. I write not to take credit for this result — my part in it was very minor — but to give an insight into the numerous obstacles that slow down even the most determined minister from finding out the truth and making the right decisions.” (link, paywalled)
There’s a lot of self-serving stuff in this essay, a little homage to Ms Truss included. There are no attacks on any of her colleagues, be they former ministers or MPs. Well, Ms B is a politician, after all and doesn’t want to be left out in the cold. There is one more pearl though:
“The Whitehall machine often becomes the voice of interest groups in government rather than government’s voice to interest groups. This stems from a sincere, yet naive, belief that you can appease special interests with platitudes and “lines to take”. The truth is some battles have to be fought and won. This requires strengthening a civil service that is terrified of controversy and recalibrating it towards policy and away from posturing on issues it believes as too “contentious”.” (link, paywalled)
And there, in a nutshell, is the history of British politics ever since politicians, ministers and ‘political writers’ and spin masters used social media as forum to push their various agendas. This has become a cancer on the body politic since BJ became PM. I look forward with trepidation as to how Labour will ‘recalibrate’ Whitehall.
I leave you with ‘news’ of another ‘catastrophe’, promoted shamelessly by that former PM Gordon Brown. The Times reports: “Worldwide education catastrophe looms unless we act, warns former prime minister Gordon Brown” (link, paywalled). It’s about an UN “educational Summit” and an accompanying poll according to which
“Forty-seven per cent of British respondents aged 16 to 30 said they did not feel equipped for the future, more than in Nicaragua, Nigeria and Indonesia and the same as in Honduras. The results reflect what experts are calling “a crisis of equity, quality and relevance” in global education.” (link, paywalled)
It’s news to me that “we” are now ‘educating children’ to the age of 30. It’s news to me that in the age of youtube our digitally clever youth is unable to access all those videos showing skills in ‘how-to’ videos or documenting history in new ways. Here are more moans:
“Thirty-seven per cent of British respondents said they did not feel valued — second only to France’s 44 per cent — and they were less optimistic about their future than young people in every other country apart from France. Twenty-two per cent of those in Britain said they were disappointed with their education.” (link, paywalled)
Oh dear. Brown and the UN Gen Sec declare this is a worldwide crisis and demand that every child in the world must go to school. The next paragraph is sickening:
“Seventy-three per cent of young people surveyed in the UK were worried about the prospect of poor education leaving millions of children without basic reading or writing skills. Sixty-seven per cent said world leaders were not doing enough to ensure all children received a good education; 77 per cent felt world leaders needed to take urgent action to fund education.” (link, paywalled)
I agree though: UK education is indeed poor when so many ‘young people’ demand ‘world leadership’ and ‘moar money’, without noticing that neither will help because this ‘world education leadership’ means that even more kids will leave school brainwashed, unable to think for themselves, functionally illiterate and innumerate, with a life-goal of becoming an ‘influencer’ on social media. They’re clearly unaware of the destruction of our educational system by Brown’s comrade and predecessor.
Is it too much to ask Mr Brown if perhaps demanding drag queens ‘teaching’ our children might rob them of time to learn letters and numbers, the basis of any further learning? It certainly is beyond the strength of any ‘education Minister’ to stand against their mandarins who’ve done for years as reported by Ms Badenoch.
Apologies for yet another grim start to a new week and month …
How about Boris Johnson the most ineffectual, laziest and incompetent prime minister of modern times getting off his backside and doing some work for a change and sort out the ever burgeoning English Channel migrant crisis out, but oh no he wont do that. This utter fool is more interested in blaming the 2019 red wall MP’s for his downfall. No you incompetent lunatic, nobody to blame for your downfall other than yourself. Taking the Covid lockdowns to a point where our economy was trashed in addition to our civil liberties and freedoms, turning the Conservative Party into a neo Green Party, introducing Green policies that nobody voted for, agreeing to a half baked deal with the European Commission which saw Northern Ireland effectively annexed by the EU with separate customs rules which has led to the province making Sin Fein the largest party in the last round of elections, shafting British fishermen leaving them worse off than before rather than standing up to the European Union and demanding 100% control of our Territorial Waters, and if those issues weren’t bad enough thinking you were somehow exempt from the laws you put into place without so much of a debate in the House of Commons concerning the Covid restrictions. I have never been convinced that Johnson was ever that interested in Britain’s independence from the EU because he didn’t want to upset those on the continent who he often referred to as our ‘friends and partners’. You have been a walking disaster zone since the 31st January 2020, and I am personally glad to see the back of you like many others who you massively let down. Don’t forget to close the door firmly behind you as you leave 10, Downing Street for the very last time, and don’t bother darkening our shores again. The man who promised so much, but delivered so little will be your legacy…..
Well said Colin. I have to wonder if all the shenanigans around the choosing of a new PM were designed to let Boris come back to the detriment of us all. I hope that you are able to post your comment far and wide.
More and more Tory heavyweights are endorsing Truss. For which read: they are now certain she will win and are greasing in the hope of a job. Sickening really.
Whereas Kemi is pressing on into all the groupthink topics that are hard to address, and avoided by the others, from wokeness to trans, to CRT to civil serpent agendas and duplicity. I am no Truss fan, except as being less of an immediate danger than Sunak, but I think we can forgive Kemi for mentioning Truss since she actually worked with her, so her opinions, especially in the light of her character, are worth hearing, and she is airing her philosophy rather than what she thinks will make her popular with her party. One hopes it is popular with Truss, though, and she does get a heavyweight portfolio.
Yes well Viv, you said ages ago that the civil servants were controlling the government and you were quite right.
I am glad this is now being said openly.
The media is more difficult because, of course, it should be free of control or censorship.
Pauline Did you really think that establishment career politicians/parties work those who elected them?
Undoubtedly Civil Serpents control the Government, as they always have. I was told this in 1975 when I moved my employment to Scotland and I became friends with my “meeter and greeter” who introduced me to the politics customs and argot of Dundee, he was an ex-seaman like me and was very definite on this, although I don`t really think he thought them malevolent (controlling) as of now.
Along with Civil Servants I would also class those NHS officials who are armed with the legitimacy of the rules of the enabling act, which until rescinded means their word is law.
Any news of either Rishi or Truss rescinding them immediately on taking office ?-( don`t make me laugh)
Jake I would also go for Suella Braverman for a big job, particularly as she ” approves” the Commonwealth and Truss says she is going to be ‘big’ on the Commonwealth as a trading partner and as I have been advocating for years
I was being sarcastic Roger! A big role in fooling the credulous centre Right!
Kemi Badenoch may find herself, by accident or design, into playing a huge role over the next two years in the run-up to the next GE – keeping the credulous centre Right voter on side. Whilst the Government presses on with its big state agenda Kemi is shaping up nicely in replacing the faded star Patel, who has lost all credibility.
Prune first then split Home office then replace their bureaucrats with coppers 2 or 3 per High Street of which i estimate there aresome 100,000 .There should be no admin or bureaucrat coppers. just working ranks.Each high street would have its own copper. The punishment for Bent Coppers should be harsh enough to make bending unattractive. Lawyers, EUCR and EU ” get stuffed. “
Gordon Brown has been UN Special Envoy for Education since 2012. In 10 years he has achieved what exacty? Declaring a crisis after all this time is an admission of failure. Brown is also a Senior Panel Member at the Kofi Annan Foundation initiative on Electoral Integrity. How’s that going?
An acquaintance, on the way to becoming a friend, returned to London recently after a 30 year stint at the UN in Geneva. I’m learning one person’s account of how the UN has changed over the last 30 years. And the more I learn, the more I believe that the UN shoud be disbanded. Like the EU, it began with noble intentions by sincere, well-meaning people and morphed into a tyrannical, self-serving racket. C S Lewis sums it up:
“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims
may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons
than omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron’s cruelty may
sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those
who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they
do so with the approval of their own conscience.”
We are tormented without end by so many.
Kemi Badenock is merely the latest in a long line of ministers who hace experienced what Tony Benn called being ‘bounced’ (manipulated) by civil servants. Benn complained in 1974, and subsequently in his 1999 Diaries: ““senior civil servants tend to view governments as visitors to the royal suite at the Grand Hotel and they themselves comprise the real permanent government”
Domininc Cummings once remarked that a hard rain was going to fall on the civil service. A few weeks later he was gone.
Yes Stout Yeoman, there is a lot of truth in what you said at 9.49 am.
I was particularly interested in the C S Lewis quote. Remember the Russian Revolution began as an attempt to get rid of the robber barons and replace it with a system operating for the good of all.
Lenin turned it into a centralised tyranny of ‘The State’ over each and every one of the subjects.
No chance, of course, of the U.N. being disbanded and I do not think it would be sensible for us to leave it.
But I do believe we should distance ourselves as far as possible from decisions made by it’s many subsidiary bodies.
Kemi Badenock … experienced … being ‘bounced’ (manipulated) by civil servants.
Not quite; it appears she experienced attempts, but recognised them and resisted. A very rare and valuable creature.
“It would be better to live under robber barons than omnipotent moral busybodies.”
But we have the worst of both worlds: robber barons in the guise of omnipotent moral busybodies.
I think she has discovered a vein of pure gold. I trust she understands theramifications.. Mind you Truss should. She is an economist et al, And her dad.
Brown clearly is corrupt. His selling our gold and the way the sale was handled is a clear demonstration of that. No other logical explanation.
All this and the prime source of bureaucracy and its propagation as well. And as if that is not enough, Legislation on top of old bad legistation making it all impenetrable and unchangeable.
To give ‘them’ their due t g s. J.R.M. has apparently been ferreting away at past E.U. bureaucratic laws and binning them.
Or so we have been told.